I just wish we knew more about stopping these crimes before they start. I do have a question, if you believe that your sister Tamar had no relationship with your father after the trial, does that mean you think Fauna lls story about George Hodel photographing and molesting her is made up? Craig: Thanks for the kind words. From where her handbag was found (Griffith Park) and Elisabeth Short was found (Leimert Park). Tamar's Real Story In 1949, two years before Fauna was born, 14-year-old Tamar visited her father, Dr. George Hodel, at his home in Hollywood. Wow! Also, how did he explain the homage to Elizabeth Short? While I provide much of what I believe to be the motive and crime signatures to his crime, (the method for his madness) separate from that is: physical evidence connecting the crime scene to the body dump location (cement sacks), police tape-recorded admissions and confessions to multiple murders, including Dahlia, as well as police payoffs and to performing abortions, police reports documenting they knew and dated each other prior to the murder, handwriting expert analysis confirming authorship of the Avenger Letters were written by GHH, four top original law enforcement officers independently corroborating each others statements that the case was solved and Dr. George Hodel did it; witness statements connecting him to the crime, and on and on. That's in the original newspaper coverage, which most people haven't read. By confirming my investigation they would confirm that fact, which they apparently decided is not acceptable. In any case, I just wanted to put that out there. His parents, George Hodel Sr. and Esther Hodel, were of Russian Jewish ancestry. 1 podcast ranking" in the United States. After moving to Hawaii, Tamar had three sons: Peace, Love (now a pro surfer), and Joy to the World Hodel. I hope many are encouraged by you who have also lived twilight zone lives no fault of their own. She was the mother of five children; Fauna Hodel, Fauna II (born Deborah Elizabeth . Tamar always loved her father and felt affection towards him, but post incest trial in 1949 they never again had any kind of relationship and dads position toward Tamar with the rest of his family was always, Lying Tamar. (He did see her on a few occasions one being a meeting of Tamars good friend, Michele Phillips when The Mamas and Papas were doing debut singing in the Sixties as he was passing through San Francisco. In 1949, Dr. George Hill Hodel was accused of molesting and having sex with his 14-year-old daughter, Tamar. Share this: Twitter Facebook Email Print Reddit Tumblr Loading. Men like that dont change and remain flat earth believers until the end. Also, how this also ties in with the fact that a hobby of your fathers what photography? Shock, anger, hatred, and now just a terrible feeling of sadness for his undeniable psychopathy and the recognition he was in truth a real life Jekyll and Hyde. Now real linkage or evidence, but then my book, Black Dahlia Avenger came out two years later and presented real evidence and the secret DA files showing George Hodel was the No.1 suspect all along and the top brass all separately and in secret claimed the case was solved and Dr. Hodel did it Harnisch, abandoned by Det. It actually made me think about a movie that I never watched (and dont intend to) called A Serbian Man. Its generally meant to group people together often based on stereotypes and ignorance, to other. So, in truth it is way beyond a reasonable doubt which is what you need to convict in a jury trial. He did see her back in the early-mid Sixties and did take Fauna II (Deborah Elizabeth, daughter of Tamar and Stan Wilson, the folksinger) out alone for dinner. Best, Steve, Thank you for your ceaseless commitment to the truth, Steve. Outraged by the audacity of their daughter and the stigma attached to a mixed-race child within their midst, her mother quickly arranged to have the baby permanently given away to Jimmie Lee, a black maid in a Nevada casino. Amnon had to finagle a way to get Tamar to visit him because the king's children dwelled in different abodes. . Based on this the HOSPITAL AUTHORITIES AND PERSONNEL ASSUMED THAT THIS FRIEND (A NEGRO) WAS THE FATHER, and Tamar continued to let them believe the father was black. Again, thanks to you and my many readers for your ongoing confidence and support. Unfortunately for us, Tamars autobiographies were never completed. Short had suffered gruesome mutilation, notably her body being cut in half at the waist, as well as her mouth being cut ear to ear. She had five children. Tamar married folk. Much appreciated. He was planning his own book naming a Dr. Walter Bayley as the killer and has been promising his readers to publish the proofs for the past twenty-four years. Hodel left the United States in March 1950 for Hawaii, then a U.S. territory, where he married an upper-class Filipino woman, Hortensia Laguda. She also told me that she always loved George, always. LAPD at that time was actively investigating the Springer and Black Dahlia murders and had publicly identified them as "probably connected". Death: March 08, 1982 (75) Santa Monica, Los Angeles County, CA, United States. I will continue to wear the dual masks of Drama (Thalia God of Comedy and Melpomene God of Tragedy). (Also, FYI, you can search any subject by using the SEARCH BOX under my badge on the Squad Room Blog page. 4. As far as the hosts of Root of Evil, I had never actually met my great niece Rasha prior to our appearance on the Dr. Phil Show a few months back and had only met her sister, Yvette on two brief occasions, with her mother Fauna, more than a decade past. Their term, not mine. Yes, DNA has proven that George Hodel WAS NOT her biological father. Both series surmise that Fauna might be both the granddaughter and the daughter of Hodel, though there is no evidence as to who her real father is. thanks, 7: Police Fauna Hodels 1951 Birth Certificate: Tamar in her own words bda III all seven pages. Also, hope to put together a Documentary, miniseries to tell the full story in six or eight episodes. Fauna 2 was born Deborah Elizabeth Wilson. Zack, the host of the show, had an agenda different than hers. As indicated in my followup books, Buster a cadaver dog alert to numerous locations for human remains. But I cant imagine how Id feel to uncover evidence that my parent had had a second career as a notoriously depraved serial killer. 2. They remained in touch with each other as long as I can remember.. her reasons to win his love and hopefully gain financial support as well. If this is true, it astounds me that he had a close enough relationship with her to name her child. She was proud to be to married to a famous recording artist, as her first love (Josh White) was already married. I hope Tamar Hodel, Fauna's birth mother, gets to write her own book. Thank you for telling your story! Sadly, that cannot change. You and your family ? I only know what she told me. Speechless. George Hill Hodel Jr. (October 10, 1907 May 17, 1999) was an American physician and suspect in the murder of Elizabeth Short, a.k.a. Tamar Hodel was Fauna Hodel 's mother. Many believe Dr. George Hodel was the killer, thanks to an investigation by Hodel's own son. Known or suspected sex criminals in the area were being investigated for the Short case, and it had come out in that trial that Tamar had allegedly claimed her father was the Dahlia killer. Dr. Hodel obtained criminal defense attorney Jerry Giesler and was acquitted after a three-week jury trial. was far more compelling and richly detailed than lmharnischs efforts at debunking your suppositions. Only source on it is Ancestry.com They thought there was something fishy. I have not read your books (yet) as I just stumbled onto your site after googling about the I am the night series after recently watching it. Theyre having so much fun!) Less impressed was active Detective Brian Carr, the LAPD officer then in charge of the Black Dahlia case which was still officially open. Stop using words like negro. I hope you are okay. Fauna naci cuando Tamar tena diecisis aos. They can't talk to my secretary anymore because she's dead. Did he remain a mystery? I am not one to get involved in petty arguments and disputes. Do I think that she gave you the middle name of Elizabeth to show her ongoing love for her father and to do as he wished and name her little doll, (this time a living doll) to please her father and fulfill his seven-year-old request, to name her Elizabeth? Thank you Steve for your drive to reveal this sad truth. Tom Hiddleston Is Officially Returning For 'The Night Manager' Season 2, 'Daisy Jones & The Six' Was Partially Inspired By This Viral Fleetwood Mac Moment, Randy Roth From 'A Rose For Her Grave' Is Still In Prison, Here's When You Can Watch The Final Season Of 'The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel', Get Even More From Bustle Sign Up For The Newsletter. I made no review about her book from its publication (2008) until just a few months past, so 11-years of no comment.. Steve, Steve, Tamar gives us the true story of how once she was hospitalized, a very kind and loving Black man offered to help meoffered to marry me, but authorities refused. That is when he drugged her and took the naked photographs in the hotel room. 4: Salesperson (oh crap thats me) Ill admit, the expression sets my teeth on edge, as it seems I only ever hear it when some jackass is making a belittling comment to someone, attempting to make the person feel they are other than what is acceptable. When she sought out her birth mother Tamar years later, she found out about her. (On his blog site Harnisch informs his readers that he hasnt and doesnt read my books.), My father had a total lack of empathy for anyone. Thank you. In the first episode of their I Am the Night companion podcast, Root of Evil, they featured a recording of their mother talking about when she first met Tamar and her brothers and sister in Hawaii. That's a lie. Thanks for the kind words. Hodel purchased the Sowden House in 1945 and lived there from 1945 until 1950. But things may get even more complicated for her when she discovers Tamar had other children after giving her up for adoption. By around 1928, Hodel was in a common-law marriage with a woman named Emilia; they had a son, Duncan. Head Deputy District Attorney Stephen Kay described himself as highly impressed by Steve Hodel's research and conclusions and even went so far as to declare the case had been solved. Fauna's birth father was unknown, and the troubled Tamar gave up Fauna for adoption. Fauna's story technically begins in 1951, when 16-year-old Tamar Hodel gave birth to a baby girl. At that time she and no one else had a clue that I was investigating our father for suspected crimes. I expect you would have Mr. Burns go back and edit out all the live footage that clearly demonstrated and used the real-life 1920s and 1930s racist references to lynchings and the use of Nigger and Negro from the script. But, no relationship and he went out of his way to avoid any contact with Tamar. I could not continue to be Deborah, to abused, to damaged, even after being lent overnight to wealthy men finally stopped Tamar kept abusing me in every way possible, I was so brainwashed it was many years to realize what she was doing to me still. Fauna never met George Hodel and was never in the Sowden/Franklin House until long after her grandfathers death in 1999. Unless mom, Tamar told YOU differently then what I am saying. I suppose thats a normal reaction when pondering a sociopathic ghoul who hates women and is incapable of feeling compassion, warmth, or tenderness for fellow human beings. In the evening, a cook shot himself in the head while inside his hotel room after failing to reconcile with his wife and child. She was eighty years old. Thank you for the kind words and well wishes to me and my readers. I also wish our police personal were honored more for all that they do to keep us safe. [1] Told she was multiracial, Fauna was raised by Jimmie Lee Greenwade (later Faison)[2] and given the name "Patricia Ann Greenwade". Yet, it very much is. [9] [10] Another book, an autobiography by a daughter of Tamar Hodel who was given up for adoption, is the inspiration for a fictionalized drama mini-series about the Black Dahlia murder by director Patty Jenkins, scheduled to air in 2019. . Two weeks ago today, my half-sister, Tamar Nais Hodel, passed away in her sleep. These photographs, taken at the Hodel home, picture Kelvin, Michael and Steven Hodel. The three-page letter identified W. Glenn Martin as a paid LAPD police informant working for a "Sgt. Fauna's Daughters Have Given Their Stamp Of Approval,", "New Podcast Explores Black Dahlia Murder: Root of Evil dives into the story of George Hodel, a primary suspect in Elizabeth Shorts 1947 unsolved murder and its told by his great-granddaughters,", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fauna_Hodel&oldid=1133379049, This page was last edited on 13 January 2023, at 13:52. As Tamar revealed to DuJour, Fauna was the product of a sexual assault. The DA tapes recorded him saying:[2][4]. Next? She stated she wanted to be involved in the seance with the intention of having the medium free any spirits of victims remaining in house. Tamar watches her father hold a party no child should witness, a full-on Satanic looking sex orgy with George Hodel front and center wearing what looks like an animal skull. In my young mind it was my way to be New, loved, a person not sexually abused!! In fact she spoke of George this way even years after your first book: Black Dahlia Advenger. Born august 1, 1951, in san francisco, hodel was the first child of 16-year-old tamar nais hodel and the granddaughter of los angeles doctor and socialite george na's birth father was unknown, and the troubled tamar gave up fauna for adoption. Though the father was. In an interview conducted by the authors on August 16, 2005, Tamar . However, unlike Robert "Red" Manley, Hodel was never considered an important suspect in the case: there is no credible evidence that Hodel even knew Short or had any connection to her homicide. Steve Hodel has since produced two additional books on the Dahlia case, and several books on the Zodiac killer and other cases, attempting to link them to his father. [7], Her memoir One Day She'll Darken: The Mysterious Beginnings of Fauna Hodel[1] (written with J. R. Briamonte) was published by Outskirts Press in 2008. read my books. The reason being that her mother Dorothy Anthony Barbe Hodel was originally from Portland, Oregon and married a symphony conductor from that city. (The reason being to hide the fact that a murder was committed during the electronic stakeout and they took no action, made no immediate response to the assault.) No, never did ID that victim. Sincerely, Carr took the position, Could be him? Ive wondered about her for years, but didnt know who or where to ask. So, very possible she was at that school prior to coming down for the fateful events that occurred in the Summer of 49? Two years before Fauna was even born, Tamar. Working on The Early Years which will hopefully be the last book in the series and will cover his crimes from the Twenties and Thirties, so stay tuned. In the summer of 1949, the 14-year-old moved into the Franklin Avenue house. Fauna with Jimmie Lee. After Tamar gave birth to Fauna, her maturity began to appear and she eventually had four additional children, Elizabeth (also known as Fauna II), and three boys, Peace, Love and Joy. I felt a similar response in my body when I first learned about your father. Are you investigating your fathers activity in Asia? Even then, I tend to leave room for the story to change, if that makes sense. Of course, my niece, Fauna in real life never met my father, nor was she ever at the Sowden/Franklin House until long after his death in 1999. However, Fauna never knew her grandfather, as her mother, Tamar Hodel, gave her up for adoption in 1951, four years after the Black Dahlia's murder, when Tamar was only 16. five brothers all who were coal miners in PA, and my grandfathers parents You wrote you people not in bad faith, but as a result of your misinterpretation. Thank you. Oh please spare me with the, you people comment. Remember, this case came to me, I didnt go to it. Just put in a keyword or two. Was Fauna Hodel the child of incest, and the catalyst for a sensational trial that left her well-to-do family scarred by scandal, even as the accused sexual predator walked free? [2] Hodel's medical degree also aroused suspicion, given the hypothesis that whoever bisected Short's body had some degree of surgical skill. whats next? is there any further movement on the testing of the DNA on the envelope, which your father sealed? 1. When others listen to Root of Evil my bothers statements bear out mine, as to the warped relationship she keep with George. He was a copyeditor of the LA Times who had dreams of solving the Black Dahlia Murder with Birthplace: 711 12th Avenue, New York, New York County, NY, 10019, United States. Surely they made links between the imagery? Other than that, if at all possible, I wish you peace of mind !! For your information, this old guy doesnt have a racist bone in his body thanks to my mothers teaching and raising me and my brothers to love and respect ALL RACES from our childhood. In 1961, at 17, Phillips followed Hodel to San Francisco, where her friend bought her a fake ID and a black cocktail dress, taking her to clubs to meet comedians like Lenny Bruce and Dick. Hyde that won the battles for his psyche. Tamar responded with a photo of herself with her four other children, whom she had after giving Fauna up for adoption daughter Elizabeth (who was also called Fauna II) and sons Peace, Love, and Joy. Fauna 2 changed her name from Deborah to Fauna I believe to honor Fauna I and because her mother, Tamar always expressed a fondness for her unknown long ago adopted first child. He had no part in the naming. DuJour reports that Tamar eventually moved to Hawaii with Debbie (who changed her name to Fauna-Elizabeth), and had three sons. Thanks for the kind words. In 1940, Hodel married Dorothy Harvey, John Huston's ex-wife. Grandfather, REALLY twisted her mind & values. Omg that woman ,Why be offended by something and tell someone off for quoting something someone else in the context of the story has said then go and use that word amongst others themselves their hypocrisy knows no bounds No-one would believe anything bad someone says about you Steve your record speaks for itself , I personally wouldnt put it past that person whos dissed you publicly on their website for 18 + years like LH to pose as a woman S or L on your site to troll you for kicks or attention ( ironic and twisted if true considering GH used to do something similar to people of his former profession as Zodiac ). Supposin' I did kill the Black Dahlia. (Thirteen of these crimes were originally investigated and believed serially connected by the San Diego Sheriff's and Police Departments back in the 1930s, but a suspect was never identified.) "Things could not get any more weird . or so we thought," Gentile said of the situation. See blog on it HERE. For you, thank you for giving your readers and podcasts listeners a glimpse into such a traumatic time into your life as you fought to uncover such an ugly truth about your own father. When Elizabeth Short, also known as The Black Dahlia, was brutally killed in 1947, it gripped the entire country. Because her father was listed on her birth certificate as an "unknown Negro", Fauna ended up with an African-American family in Reno, Nevada. That's a lie. I know he had McCawley" (Sgt. In January 2019, the American TV network TNT simultaneously aired two "companion" productions. They cant defeat the evidence, so all they can do is continue to claim we are too busy with other cold cases to look at Hodels investigation. I wanted to let you know that I just finished Root of Evil and I thought your work on it was amazing! The school itself was Oregon Episcopal School. Wishing you and yours continued health in the very difficult times. Tamar and her half-brother, Steve, remember their father's house as a place. Tamar Hodel was a girl with a difficult life despite being born in the upper class. Soon after, the father and daughter were. Now, in the upcoming Feb. 25 episode, Fauna and Jay will journey to Hawaii to find her. Involuntarily worldly. No movement on DNA testing by LAPD. But, LAPD claimd they are too busy to do any followup. No luminol ever test back then or through the decades. When questioned by the police, she said she had left because "her home life was too depressing," on account of "all. However disgusting and disturbing A Serbian Film might be, I think there are some striking parallels between the madness of the main antagonist and George Hodel, so I encourage you to watch the preview and read the Wikipedia article. Aloha: Directed by Carl Franklin. At the same time, I would caution against using the expression you people. Geraldine M or Martha J: I just watched the episode of Zak on the Black Dahlia murder with Fauna. Christina: In 1949, George Hodel had been arrested and tried for incest by LAPD; his 14-year-old daughter Tamar accused him of raping her, resulting in a pregnancy she aborted. Thanks for your thoughtful response Steve. And I just got a chill upon reading that he told her to name her doll Elizabeth. Tamar Hodel. According to George, A sexual relationship between a father and a daughter is normal. He was a musical prodigy as a child and performed as a solo pianist in several concerts at Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles. Thank you. [1] He was never formally charged with the crime. Hodel's daughter, Tamar, escaped the house in 1949 after accusing her father and others of sexually assaulting her during one of the many parties he would throw at the estate. They corroborate your findings surely its more than bad PR? skh. The podcast also features audio from old interviews with Hodel's biological mother Tamar (who died in 2015), as well as George Hodel's son Steve (Fauna's uncle), who has claimed his father was . Yes, Im well aware of Mr. Harnischs derogatory comments over the past two decades. The jury, which included eight women, said no. Thanks for the kind words. As Tamar's half-brother Steve shared on his blog, Tamar died in 2015 at the age of 80. Fauna second row extreme right at her first grade photo shoot. Tamar claimed she had posed for nude photos for Man Ray when she was just a child. Harnisch has been on a childish rant ever since and keeps promising to publish his book any year now. The show ran for eight consecutive weeks and attained a "No. If I think about your father at length, I feel deeply uneasy. Even the Doctor who was thought to be Jack the Ripper managed to kill many women and then move to another state continuing to con people out of money as well. I particularly remember she had a picture on her bureau and Im reasonably sure it was her father. Good Morning Mr Hodel, Top 10 Professions favoured by Psychopaths She is a character in 'I Am the Night' primarily portrayed by Jamie Anne Allman. Absolutely fascinating story but how is it that you were none the wiser to your exwifes deceptions. It just seems like itd be difficult to do the things youve insisted he did if the man understood the nature of love and had his humanity intact} Im amazed at your perseverance, working tirelessly to uncover the terrible crimes of your late father. That happened. One question I cant get out of my mind: Did anyone ever determine who may have been screaming during the police recording? 9: Chef I remember reading about her daughters being so glad that her story was finally going to be told on screen after Faunas passing and I was truly disappointed when I finally watched IATN. (Her father was folksinger, Stan Wilson.). Fauna 1 who died in 2017 and Fauna II (originally named Deborah Elizabeth, but changed her name to Fauna as an adult.) Thank you for the response, Steve. The 1949 sexual abuse trial involving George Hodel's daughter Tamar is what garnered the interest of investigators on the Short homicide. Hodel graduated from Berkeley pre-med in June 1932. , In this opening introduction, Tamar presents me with the details of her teenage pregnancy and exactly how it happened and what followed during her placement in an unwed mothers home., Tamar gives us the true story of how once she was hospitalized, a very kind and loving Black man offered to help meoffered to marry me, but authorities refused. From there, authorities found evidence that led them to believe that Dr. Hodel was also a . Hi Steve, Spoilers aside, as it is such an old film, part of the impact of the last few scenes has to do with the fact that Noah Cross gets away with it. Ps. George is a monster to an unimaginable degree but the good he gave this earth came in the form of you, your siblings, nieces and nephews. The Hodels lived in a Hollywood Home, designed to look like an Mayan Temple, with hidden passageways and secret panels. Born August 1, 1951, in San Francisco, Hodel was the first child of 16-year-old Tamar Nais Hodel and the granddaughter of Los Angeles doctor and socialite George Hodel. Tamar Hodel Another person pulled from real life, Tamar had an immensely troubled childhood. My roots on my mothers side go back to County Donegal, Ireland. C. Crow, C. Crow: She would have been 13 I believe. [2] After another four children, they divorced in the 1960s; she was later a member of the Philippine Congress as Hortensia Starke. However, suspicion of Hodel was not publicly known until decades later. Nevertheless, Id have to dive deep into the sea of evidence youve provided before I could feel more confident. Lisa K: I havent watched the miniseries either, the trailer was enough to tell me is is 95% fiction. Many. In 1947 just months after murdering Elizabeth Short, George told her to name the doll Elizabeth. [2] The full details of the investigation came to light only in 2003, when a "George HodelBlack Dahlia File" was discovered in archives at the Los Angeles County District Attorney's office. George Hodel's lawyer ran an all-out smear campaign against Tamar, calling her a promiscuous, incorrigible, pathological liar, and the physician was acquitted. He had impregnated the woman and wanted to raise their child together, but she refused. Thank you for allowing the public to know the truth. Though truth be told it never was. She immediately gave her up for adoption. No, recent DNA testing has eliminated and dispelled the rumor that George Hodel was her father. ", "BLACK DAHLIA MURDER: Retired LAPD detective reveals new evidence pointing to prime suspect his father", "Root of Evil: The True Story of the Hodel Family and the Black Dahlia", "Anatomy of a Podcast: Root of Evil: The True Story of the Hodel Family and the Black Dahlia- DNA Test Answers Question of Fauna Hodel's Paternity", "A Rare Tour of Dr. George Hodel's Whimsically Weird Childhood House", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=George_Hodel&oldid=1140979512, Michael, Steven, and Kelvin Hodel, sons by Harvey, This page was last edited on 22 February 2023, at 19:11.